Hospital Horror: Alcohol Shots, Toenails Ripped Out

Doctor using tablet beside hospital patient
Photo: Pressmaster / Shutterstock

A Hillsboro podiatrist now faces two lawsuits in one week, both accusing him of injecting patients with rubbing alcohol instead of numbing medicine before yanking out their toenails.

Story Snapshot

  • Sarah Blackman sued Dr. Colin Mizuo and Kaiser Permanente, alleging he injected 70% isopropyl rubbing alcohol into each toe instead of lidocaine.
  • Her lawsuit comes about a week after another Kaiser patient, identified as Young, filed a nearly identical claim against the same doctor at the same clinic.
  • Both complaints describe severe pain during the procedures and lasting injuries, including tissue death, nerve damage, and disfigurement.
  • Young is seeking $23 million in damages, while Blackman and her husband are seeking $13 million.
  • Kaiser says patient safety is its highest priority and that it is reviewing the care provided.

Two Patients, One Doctor, Strikingly Similar Stories

The two lawsuits center on Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center in Hillsboro, Oregon. Court filings say Young’s procedure happened January 22, 2026, and Blackman’s followed just a week later, on January 29. Both complaints name Dr. Colin Mizuo and allege he used rubbing alcohol in place of a local anesthetic before removing toenails.

Blackman’s complaint, filed in Multnomah County Circuit Court, says she went in for a routine bilateral toenail-removal procedure to treat two ingrown nails. Instead of lidocaine, the suit claims, Mizuo injected roughly 4 milliliters of 70% isopropyl alcohol into each toe. Young’s complaint describes a nearly identical dose, about 4 cubic centimeters, injected in place of the expected numbing drug.

Screaming Through The Procedure

Both women describe the same horror in the room. Young said she cried, screamed, and told the podiatrist she was in “terrible pain” as he continued working. Blackman’s suit alleges her toenail was pulled without any working anesthetic at all, leaving her to endure the pain of the extraction fully aware. Oregon Live’s headline on the story used one blunt word: “torture”.

The injuries described in both complaints go far beyond a bad afternoon at the doctor’s office. Plaintiffs allege chemical burns, tissue death known as necrosis, permanent nerve damage, numbness, chronic burning pain, bone injury, and trouble walking or bearing weight on the affected foot. Both also claim lasting psychological harm from the experience. Medical staff reportedly first treated Blackman’s injuries as a simple infection, unaware of what had allegedly caused it.

Kaiser’s Response And What Comes Next

Kaiser has not disputed the broad facts publicly but has kept its comments general. A spokesperson said patient safety is the organization’s highest priority and that Kaiser reviews patient-safety events and takes appropriate action when problems are identified. Dr. Mizuo has not issued a public statement addressing either lawsuit, and reporting indicates he has since left Kaiser.

Both cases remain in the lawsuit stage, meaning the allegations have not yet been proven in court. Still, the pattern is hard to ignore: two patients, one physician, one clinic, and strikingly matching accounts of being injected with the wrong substance before an already painful procedure. Medication mix-ups are a known hazard in health care broadly, with wrong-drug errors a well-documented category of harm, but allegations this specific and this repeated demand real answers from Kaiser, not just boilerplate reassurances about safety priorities.

For families who trust Kaiser with routine outpatient care, the appeal of accountability is simple. If a doctor substituted a disinfectant for anesthesia not once but reportedly twice in the same week, patients deserve a straight answer about how that happened and what safeguards failed. Lawsuits will test the claims in court, but the dual filings alone are reason enough for Kaiser to explain itself clearly and quickly.

Sources:

washingtontimes.com, wthr.com, kptv.com, oregonlive.com, koin.com

© standardnewsdaily.com 2026. All rights reserved.